Methodology
How we score
Every score is built from public evidence anyone can check, applied with the same rubric to every firm in a category. No firm can pay for a better score, and we do not accept free consultations or gifts from firms we rank.
Where the evidence comes from
- The firm's own website: fee language, practice pages, attorney bios, published claims.
- Better Business Bureau profiles: rating, accreditation, 3-year complaint counts.
- Regulators and courts: the CFPB complaint database and enforcement actions, state attorney general registries (including the Maryland structured settlement transferee registry), FINRA rules and investor alerts.
- Independent review platforms such as Avvo, counted only where a review count is visible.
- Investigative journalism, cited by name, when it concerns a specific firm.
Current scores use evidence collected November 19, 2026. A firm's own statements are labeled as its own claims. Where we could not verify a fact, we score it as missing rather than guess.
Attorneys
| Factor | Max points |
|---|---|
| Annuity focus | 15 |
| Fee clarity | 20 |
| Lead attorney experience | 20 |
| Independent reviews | 15 |
| Accuracy of marketing claims | 20 |
| Licensing transparency | 10 |
- Annuity focus (15): 3 or more annuity-specific practice pages earn 15, 2 earn 12, 1 earns 9. A firm that only brings class actions earns 8, because most single-contract owners will not fit its model.
- Fee clarity (20): a published contingency percentage earns 20 (16 if the client pays case costs); "no fees and no expenses unless we recover" 18; "contingency only, owe nothing without a recovery" 17; "no recovery, no fee" 15; "no fee until we win" 14 (costs not addressed); hedged wording 13; contingency silent on costs 10; contingency, hourly and hybrid all offered 9; fees not published 5; only a free consultation stated 4.
- Lead attorney experience (20): 25+ years since admission earns 20, 15 to 24 earns 16, 8 to 14 earns 12, no named attorney or year earns 8. Years taken only from third-party listings are scored at 75%.
- Independent reviews (15): Avvo reviews of the lead attorneys, counted the same way for every firm. Testimonials on the firm's own site do not count. 20+ reviews earn 15, 10 to 19 earn 12, 5 to 9 earn 9, 1 to 4 earn 6, none earns 2.
- Accuracy of marketing claims (20): starts at 20. We subtract 6 for an unverifiable success-rate claim, 6 for a founding or experience claim that conflicts with the public record, 4 for results on an annuity page not shown to be annuity cases, 4 when the firm's own pages contradict each other, 2 for each unverifiable superlative, badge or volume claim, and 2 for city pages with no office.
- Licensing transparency (10): admissions and years listed on the firm's own bios earn the most; admissions found only on third-party listings earn less.
Cash-out buyers
| Factor | Max points |
|---|---|
| Years in business | 15 |
| BBB standing | 15 |
| Complaint load | 15 |
| Regulatory record | 20 |
| Price transparency | 20 |
| Court approval and registration | 15 |
- Years in business (15): verified start date (BBB or state record) of 2000 or earlier earns 15, 2001 to 2010 earns 12, 2011 to 2015 earns 9, later earns 6.
- BBB standing (15): A+ and accredited 15, A+ not accredited 10, A not accredited 8.
- Complaint load (15): BBB complaints in the last 3 years. 0 to 1 earns 15, 2 to 5 earns 13, 6 to 20 earns 10, 21 to 100 earns 6, over 100 earns 3.
- Regulatory record (20): no actions found earns 20. Closed investigations, bankruptcies and investigative press reduce it. Companies with enforcement judgments or license revocations are excluded, not ranked.
- Price transparency (20): no buyer publishes discount rates. A written statement that the quote equals the payout, with a written disclosure, earns 14; vague "low fees" language earns 6; nothing earns 3.
- Court approval and registration (15): 8 for explaining the court approval process on the site, 7 for appearing on the Maryland structured settlement transferee registry.
- Deductions: 4 points when the company's own pages contradict each other. Problems we saw but do not score, such as a site that failed to load or a missing registry listing, are shown as flags.
Exit and review firms
| Factor | Max points |
|---|---|
| Discloses how it gets paid | 25 |
| Room for a 'keep it' answer | 20 |
| Verifiable licensing | 15 |
| Track record | 15 |
| BBB standing | 15 |
| Accuracy of claims | 10 |
- Discloses how it gets paid (25): the most important factor, because every firm on this list earns money if you move. Plain, specific disclosure earns the most.
- "Keep it" is a real answer (20): does the review include keeping the contract as an outcome, or does every exit route through a product the firm sells?
- Verifiable licensing (15): a published license number or NPN you can look up earns the most. Until we have checked the number in the state database, it earns at most 12.
- Track record (15), BBB standing (15) and accuracy of claims (10) round out the score.
Grades
80 and above: Strong. 65 to 79: Solid. 50 to 64: Mixed. Below 50: Weak. A Weak grade does not mean a firm is dishonest; it usually means the public record is too thin to recommend it.
What scores do not measure
We cannot see outcomes for individual clients, private settlements or the quality of advice in a phone call. A high score means a firm is transparent and clean on the public record, not that it will win your case or pay the best price. Always get the fee agreement or the discount rate in writing.
Mistakes and disputes
If a firm shows us a fact is wrong, we fix it and rescore within 10 business days. See corrections and disputes.