Exit and review firms / #2 of 4
My Annuity Store
Online annuity agency that writes a free 5 to 8 page analysis of your existing contract.
Hamlet, IN · since 2020 · 1-855-277-8088
75 out of 100 Solid
Best for: A written report you can take to anyone
What stands out
- Free written 'Professional Annuity Analysis' delivered in 7 to 10 business days
- Report includes 'keep it' as an outcome
- 31 BBB reviews
Watch for
- Paid by commission. Audit outcomes include products it sells.
How they charge, in their words
"earn a commission from the issuing carrier if you decide to make a change"Source
Scorecard
| Factor | Points | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Discloses how it gets paid | 22/25 | Says it earns a commission from the carrier if you decide to make a change. |
| Room for a 'keep it' answer | 14/20 | Its written audit has three outcomes, one of which is keeping the contract. |
| Verifiable licensing | 11/15 | Says it is licensed in 47 states; variable annuities through First Palladium, LLC, Member FINRA. Not yet looked up. |
| Track record | 6/15 | Founded 2020. |
| BBB standing | 15/15 | BBB A+, accredited, 1 complaint and 31 reviews. |
| Accuracy of claims | 7/10 | Same page lists two different premium totals ($111MM+ and $130 million+). |
| Total | 75/100 | Full rubric |
Sources
- Company website: myannuitystore.com
- Fee language: myannuitystore.com/free-annuity-audit/
Evidence collected November 19, 2026. Ratings and complaint counts change; check the source before you rely on one. Firm statements are labeled as the firm's own claims. Is something wrong? Request a correction.
Compare with
- The Annuity Expert 86/100
- Fisher Investments Annuity Evaluation Program 67/100
- Stan The Annuity Man 47/100